Who stole the _____ from the cookie jar!

[ApolloMew]

I believe I stole all those jars due to a misunderstanding. Oh well.

Who stole the melon from the cookie jar?

[Domsters931]

I stole them melon from the cookie jar
Who stole the pumpkin from the cookie jar?

[ApolloMew]

I stole the pumpkin from the cookie jar.

Who stole the Anna Banana from the cookie jar?

[Bush2003]

I stole Anna Banana from the cookie jar! 

Who stole the Thoatt from the cookie jar?

[ApolloMew]

I stole the Thoatt from the cookie jar!

Who stole the bread from the cookie jar!

[Domsters931]

I stole the bread from the cookie jar.
Who stole the Mickey cloning device from the cookie jar?

[ApolloMew]

I didn't... who stole it? :O

Who stole the Famcraft from the cookie jar?

[socks1stormy1]

I didnt..
Who Stole the ocelot from the cookie jar?

[ApolloMew]

I stole to ocelot from the cookie jar!

Who stole the Cheese Puff's from the cookie jar! D:

[mathfreak2]

Supermickey24 stole the cheese puffs from the cookie jar.

Who stole the TARDIS (Time And Relative Dimensions In Space) from the cookie jar?

[ApolloMew]

Btw, I put the Cheese Puffs in the cookie jar, I will never break the Cheese Puff Oath.

I didn't steal the TARDIS from the jar, as I don't want to.

Who stole the Rowan from the Cookie jar?

[Domsters931]

I stole the Rowan from the cookie jar. Rowan...  I'm not sure why u were in the cookie jar but ok.
                Who stole the elephant from the cookie jar

[Springmango]

I stole the elephant from the cookie jar, he just looked so sad in there....
Who stole the soda from the cookie jar?

[ApolloMew]

I stole the soda from the cookie jar

Who stole the Air from the cookie jar?

[~Lucario~]

i stole the air from the cookie jar! then breathed it in, cause it tasted like cookies!!
  who stole the antimatter from the cookie jar?