Who stole the _____ from the cookie jar!

[PegLegPegasus]

I stole ur slippers from the cookie jar, my feet were cold

who stole the post-its from the cookie jar

[wilsondhp]

I stole the post-its from the cookie jar!

      Who stole the wizard from the cookie jar?

[IronBlu]

you did... so wait if you stole the wizard... why are you asking... Who stole him :O

Who stole Who from the cookie jar?

[FrodoRose]

I stole the cookie jar in the cookie jar in the cookie jar!
Who stole the cat from the cookie jar?


(how in the world would a cat fit in a jar)

[~Lucario~]

I stole the cat, then took it as a pet
   Who stole the Fox News channel in the cookie jar on tv?

[ApolloMew]

I did. Then I ate it.

Who stole Rowan's brand new calculator from the cookie jar?

[FrodoRose]

I stole Rowan's brand new calculator form the cookie jar!

Who stole the iPhone from the cookie jar?!

[~Lucario~]

I stole eGi from the cookie jar (I have no idea why, I just kinda did it)
   Who stole Poseidon from the underwater cookie jar?

[ApolloMew]

I did! Now I never need to bring a water bottle to basketball practice!

Who stole the chocolate jar from the cookie jar?

[ApolloMew]

I stole the yogurt! Then I eated it.

Who stole the Forum game from the cookie jar?

[IronBlu]

you did so only your forum games are left :O

who stole Famcraft FTB from the cookie jar

[~Lucario~]

I stole famcraft FTB from the cookie jar, If I can't use it, nobody can >: P
   Who stole the *PARTY* the cookie jar?

[IronBlu]

No one did it's still in there, though I don't think you'll fit in there to get to the party XD

Who stole my Sky Island building co. From the cookie jar?

[~Lucario~]

I did then I cut open a firework, poured the powder out, and put the powder in the napkin and threw in a campfire to watch the crazy firework explosions

[IronBlu]

you didn't ask Who stole the _____ from the cookie jar! so no one stole anything from the cookie jar

Who stole the bacon from the cookie jar?